NerdWallet's monthly dividend page works in two steps: rank monthly payers by yield, then apply a screen, payout ratios under 100 percent, and publish the survivors. Our dataset is smaller than NerdWallet's universe, exactly 12 monthly payers among its 197 companies (records dated September 15, 2026), which makes the exercise more pointed, not less: here is the whole shelf, ranked, with the screen applied in the open. Five of the twelve pass. The highest yield on the shelf belongs to a passer, which is not how this usually goes.
The full ranking, screened
| Ticker | Yield | Payout ratio | Payout screen |
|---|---|---|---|
| AGNC | 14.27% | 76.51% | Passes |
| PFLT | 13.67% | 188.24% | Fails |
| GOOD | 9.30% | 232.35% | Fails |
| GLAD | 9.29% | 87.38% | Passes |
| EPR | 6.35% | 119.23% | Fails |
| GAIN | 6.04% | 22.97% | Passes |
| LAND | 5.87% | Not meaningful | Excluded |
| MAIN | 5.64% | 81.52% | Passes |
| O | 5.40% | 237.23% | Fails |
| LTC | 5.39% | 84.13% | Passes |
| SLG | 4.71% | 102.26% | Fails |
| ADC | 4.58% | 172.32% | Fails |
AGNC tops the yield table at 14.27 percent and passes at a 76.51 percent payout ratio. Below it the screen does its work: PFLT yields 13.67 percent on a 188.24 percent payout, GOOD yields 9.30 on 232.35, and both fail. GLAD (9.29 percent yield, 87.38 payout) and GAIN (6.04, 22.97, the most conservative ratio on the shelf) pass, as do MAIN and LTC further down. LAND is excluded rather than failed: its recorded payout ratio is negative because its recorded earnings are negative, the same artifact this site flags wherever it appears, so the ratio is printed as not meaningful instead of as a number.
The Aristocrat fails the screen
The shelf's one Aristocrat, Realty Income (O), yields 5.40 percent and fails at a recorded 237.23 percent payout ratio. That number needs its context: O is a REIT, and REIT payout ratios against GAAP earnings routinely print above 100 percent because depreciation runs through earnings while the cash keeps flowing; the Kings and Aristocrats data on this site has carried that caveat since the monthly Kings post. The screen is a blunt instrument, applied uniformly on purpose. It clears the five names above and it would clear O on an FFO basis this dataset does not record. Both facts belong on the page.
What the screen is for
A monthly payer yielding 13 percent on a 188 percent payout is paying you partly out of your own capital's return path, which is why the yield ranking alone misleads and why the winner's format pairs the two columns. The five passers span 14.27 down to 5.39 percent, so the screen does not force a choice between safety and yield so much as it deletes the shelf's traps. The full monthly list with pay dates is in the monthly list post; build a target income from the passers in the Dividend Income Builder. Sources: the modeled page is NerdWallet's highest-yielding monthly dividend stocks; all figures are from our dataset, as captioned.